Tuesday, September 3, 2013

The Grand Slam and the Basics of Trademark Law

The organizers of the “Grand Slam of Ultrarunning TM” have invented a new controversy in the last week.  I’m a lawyer and an ultrarunner (retired), so I’ve gotten some emails asking my opinion on the subject.

Before I begin, here’s what the organizers are saying:

The Grand Slam of Ultrarunning™ Committee and the Wasatch Front 100 Mile Endurance Run Committee do not endorse, recognize, or ratify anyone or their times involved in the so-called “unofficial” grand slam of ultrarunning. Likewise we do not support, encourage, or sustain anyone involved in this pursuit.

We continue to recognize, applaud, and award the runners who are legitimately registered in and officially complete The Grand Slam of Ultrarunning™.

We also remind all who are observing or otherwise involved that the term “Grand Slam of Ultrarunning™” is a trademark of The Grand Slam of Ultrarunning™ entity, and only those who are official entrants and finishers of The Grand Slam of Ultrarunning™ are entitled to use the term “Grand Slam of Ultrarunning™” in whatever form (including in any form that might cause trademark confusion) in connection with their running endeavors.

The site was updated on 8/30/2013. I can’t be certain, but I have a strong feeling the new ™ language is a direct jab at Nick Clark, who is running the four races that comprise the slam without paying Steve Baugh an additional $80 so that he can get a trophy and be recognized by Steve Baugh.  Nick Clark, along with Ian Sharman, is one of two men who will likely break the record for the fastest man to run those four races in one summer. We can guess that Mr. Baugh doesn't like the idea that a potential record holder would circumvent the registration process he created for the event. Thus, the controversy.

Some trademark basics:

First, if someone uses the ™ symbol, that means that they are asserting common law trademark rights or that they plan to register a federal trademark in the future. If someone uses the ® symbol, that means they already possess a registered federal trademark. Given that Mr. Baugh not used the  ® symbol, we can assume that no official (federal) agency has yet recognized any trademark right to this name.  Nor was I able to find a registered state trademark in Utah. To my knowledge, the only official filing on record is a “dba filing” under Steven Baugh’s name with the Utah Secretary of State from October of last year. So there is no "Grand Slam of Ultrarunning Entity." It's just a name under which Steve Baugh does business. 

As of now, Mr. Baugh is merely asserting that he has a trademark to the "Grand Slam" name. Most likely, no state or federal agency has yet confirmed such a claim. 

What does all that mean? Basically, without federal or state registration, Baugh has very limited enforcement rights under common law trademark principles.  What’s more, until last week, it’s unclear whether anyone even knew that there was anyone who cared to enforce this purported trademark (not registered locally or federally). That's certainly the consensus from the comments in this article. That's another strong argument against his ability to enforce such a right. 

Second, even if Mr. Baugh does have a trademark right to assert, he still cannot prevent “nominative” uses of the trademarked name.

What’s a nominative use?

The most famous case on this subject is Kids on the Block v. News America Publishing, Inc., 971 F.2d 302 (9th Cir. 1992).  Basically, in this case, the New Kids on the Block sued USA Today for having a poll that asked readers who their favorite “New Kid” was (clearly Donnie, in my case).  The New Kids said that USA Today was profiting on their trademarked name. According to the court, “[i]t is no more reasonably possible . . . to refer to the New Kids as an entity than it is to refer to the Chicago Bulls, Volkswagens or the Boston Marathon without using the trademark.” In the end, the court decided that using the New Kids name in the poll was permissible use.

The court applied the following standard to determine what is permissible use when using someone's trademarked name:

“First, the product or service in question must be one not readily identifiable without use of the trademark; second, only so much of the mark or marks may be used as is reasonably necessary to identify the product or service, and third, the user must do nothing that would, in conjunction with the mark, suggest sponsorship or endorsement by the trademark holder.” Id.

First, the Grand Slam isn’t readily identifiable by any other name. Second, everyone uses it to describe the achievement of running those four races, nothing more. Third, I don’t think anyone is implying that Nick Clark has received sponsorship or endorsement by Steve Baugh. Nor do I think anyone cares. He's made clear he believes the opposite. 

In conclusion, at present, the Grand Slam of Ultrarunning has no official state or federal trademark protection. Mr. Baugh may have some very limited rights under common law trademark because of prior use, but, even if we were to assume for the sake of argument that he does have common law rights, he almost certainly can’t prevent people from talking about, discussing, or referring directly to the “Grand Slam of Ultrarunning” as a way to describe those races.  He can only prevent people from using the name to promote races or imply sponsorship or endorsement when none exists. 


In the end, Steve Baugh wants to preserve his role in the "Grand Slam" series. But it's unclear what he might hope to achieve by engaging in this kind of aggressive territorial behavior, other than generating dissent and disagreement.  You can claim you own the trademark to the award for running those four races. That may or may not be the case. But you can't hope to claim ownership of the experience or the community's desire to recognize that accomplishment. Any such pretension is small-minded and petty. 

And that's all I have to say about that. 

50 comments:

  1. Brilliant. Thanks for the time you spent on this, Kieran!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Being a slow reader (and I did go out for a stumble), I just now got around to reading this. Thank you for your time and thoughtful writing.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kieran-Thanks so much for posting this. It clears up a LOT of questions.

    Eric Schranz
    ultrarunnerpodcast.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kieran, Thank you so much for the legal insight! I guess that really clears up the air, doesn't it?! To put it crassly, Piss off, Mr Baugh!.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I wonder if Mr. Baugh, using the same logic he is using with respect to "Grand Slam of Ultrarunning," can or should be using the names "Leadville Trail 100 Run," "Vermont 100 Mile Endurance Run," "Wasatch Front 100 Mile Endurance Run," or "Western States 100-Mile Endurance Run" to promote or explain his trophy. Maybe he has complex contractual agreements with each race spelling out name usage rights with each race. Or, maybe he doesn't...

    ReplyDelete
  6. Catching up on this topic but you summed it up perfectly. "Small minded and petty". Excellent Post!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I did the "Toy Slam of UltraRunning®™" [a purely imaginary and fictive conceit] in 1993 with WS and AC; for which I was handsomely rewarded by a chorus of "thank Gawd *thats* over with", followed by dead silence.

    ReplyDelete
  8. You know what likely holds way more bite than this silly "virtual land-grab" a.k.a. Grand Slam of Ultrarunning™ stuff...? Yep, I believe that would be a certain "Grand Slam of Breakfasts®™" (<-- also totally made up, though referring to piles of food that I'd like to eat right about now.) :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. This is a brilliant write up. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  10. The really nice thing about the ultra community is that it self-corrects away from organizations that aren't supportive of it.

    The Grand Slam as an entity is only worth what people are willing to care about it. Does anybody seriously think that the community wouldn't recognize Nick for his accomplishment if he were to win?

    If Nick wins, I for one plan to be at the ceremony to honor him with things that represent the spirit of the community -- namely, silly hats, a cold beer and a hearty congratulations and respect.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Indeed Mike Place. As an aspirant Grand Slam finisher I have watched Ian and Nick go at it in great style. If Nick overtakes Ian I plan to shake his hand as the worthy holder of the record, as will Ian I am quite sure. So it seems Slam has, de facto, loosed it's legal bonds. As you say....self correcting.

      Delete
  11. Has anybody Trademarked "Steve Baugh" yet?

    ReplyDelete
  12. As you can see now, there's quite a buzz about this, so thanks much for sharing your expertise. Pretty much everything that needed to be said has been said, so I hope Nick can just focus on his race and have fun.

    My lingering confusion in general, however, is the fact that the term had been used "freely" for some time in the community and magazines, etc. And now it's being "claimed" by people who didn't necessarily even originate it! How does *that* work?
    I would consider things like (Grand Canyon) R2R2R, Mummy Mania/Mummy Kill, Long's Peak "Grand Slam" and "Radical Slam", Pawnee-Buchanan, Maroon Bells 4-Pass Loop...perhaps even FKT itself...to be similarly analogous situations. And clearly, Nick's WS/Hardrock "Double" got some attention -- heck, Karl was shooting for it this year. It would be utterly inappropriate for me or you to try to trademark any of those, yet it feels like that's what these guys have done for Grand Slam. Granted, the "concept" has a history (late 90's, best I can tell) of being "managed" -- but only after being "unofficial" for some years before that. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like at the point they want to claim a trademark, they would need to come up with a *new* name that hadn't already been established -- but how is that proven?

    ReplyDelete
  13. A trademark is a word, name, symbol or device which is used in trade with goods to indicate the source of the goods and to distinguish them from the goods of others.

    Online trademark filing & Trademark law firms

    ReplyDelete
  14. Well great blog is very helpful to people who need information about Trademark Law .





    Personal Injury Attorney Ct & Accident Attorney Connecticut



    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Background Removal Services (BRS) is one of the best Clipping path service provider around the world. We offer our global customers: Raster to Vector Services, Photo Restoration Services Prices, Photo Neck Joint Service, Exposure Color Correction Service, Jewelry Photo, Retouching Services, Photo Color Correction Service, Image Mirror Effect Service, Cheap Retouching Services, Deep Etching Service,

    ReplyDelete
  17. أفضل شركة نقل في المدينة المنورة والنجارين المبهرين في تفكيك وتركيب الأثاث والمفروشات.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Turbo Steam is a powerful, yet portable, fabric and clothes steamer for all of your steaming needs. Our Turbo Steam takes only 45 seconds to heat up and to start generating steam and its steam delivery system evenly distributes steam across fabrics to remove even the worst wrinkles.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Using the Images Background Remover service, you can get the best possible solutions. The photos will be livelier and you can use them anywhere. The importance of Background Remover Online is undeniable for every photo. Before we move to the benefits of having the service, it is better to know about the service.

    ReplyDelete
  20. In other sense, the clipping path is like creating a path that will remove the bars from the photo. As the name suggests, it clips a path. It points that the path that you not need gets clipped. The ClippingPath Service Provider is able to bring the change in the photos. Applying the Photoshop tool, the provider does the task.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Read the Best Massager Reviews of 2019 Find out which is the best model on the market and the health benefits of using a Best Massager Reviews.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Prom Dress Hut is a prom dresses company. If you are looking for a prom dress, check out our Latest Prom Dress Collection. You can order from Prom Dresses USA, Prom Dresses UK, Prom Dresses Australia, Prom Dresses Canada, and Prom Dresses Germany.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Read the best Foot Massager Reviews of 2019 Inthe following article, we present the top 8 models available today and revealtheir pros and cons.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Photo Editing Pricing value on the images editing requirements. The exact price of you use can vary greatly. Depending on the vendor/contractor, the complexity of the image editing volume of images and how quickly you need the edited photos back Forget an idea about Our Pricing you can check our photo editing price list.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Clipping path is a must for any kinds of product images. Clipping Path Service can provide you with your desired product with a high-end view which will help you to attract both the organic customers and paid to add customers. Do Clipping Path for your business growth and show your customers what you have!

    ReplyDelete
  26. Banner Design Service is a focusing fact for any kinds of business institutions. Banner show your products identity which is provided by you. Manage your banner design service creatively by any professional designer to highlight your products. Creative banner grabs your customer’s attention.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Photo Restoration Services is a complex editing job. So, you have to be confirmed to give your desired photo in the hand of an expert photo editor. Experts do feel the alike you feel about your old photos. We can proudly ensure you that we have a huge team of editing experts! they can easily meet your photo editing demand. Do visit to test our photo restoration service quality.

    ReplyDelete


  28. يوجد عندناشركة رش مبيدات بجازان
    فريق متخصص فى تنظيف الأسطح والحدايق
    شركة كشف تسربات المياة بجازان
    ولديهم (خبرة) تستخدم أحدث الأت والمواد فى
    شركة عزل خزانات بجازان تنظيف الأسطح والحدايق ويوجد لدينا أفضل وأحسن
    شركة عزل اسطح بجازان
    خامات تنظيف التى يعتمد عليها فريق عملنا من خلال تلك المواد العالى
    شركة تنظيف مجالس بجازان
    الجودة المستخدمة فى تنظيف الأسطح والحدايق
    شركة تنظيف فلل بجازان ولهم طريقة خاص فى تنظيف الحدايق حيث يعمل على تنظيف الحديقة من خلال إزالة النفايات الموجودة فيها و التخلص أيضاً من النباتات البرية عن طريق خلعها من الجزور وكذلك الأسطح
    تنظيف مطابخ وحمامات
    يوجد لدينا أفضل
    شركة تنظيف شقق بجازان الخدمات فى تنظيف المطابخ والحمامات وتنظيف أيضاً الزوايا التى يصعب الوصول

    شركة تنظيف خزانات بجازان
    إليها بأحدث الأت البخار والمواد المستخدمه فى التنظيف
    شركة صيانة مكيفات بجازان

    ReplyDelete
  29. Image Retouching is a standout amongst the most noteworthy administrations in Image altering. It expedites a positive vibe and look the Image. The majority of the end-level clients are in extraordinary necessities of image retouching Services. Be that as it may, you should be cautious while choosing the best one.Chat discussion end Type a message....

    ReplyDelete

  30. Image Retouching is a standout amongst the most noteworthy administrations in Image altering. It expedites a positive vibe and look the Image. The majority of the end-level clients are in extraordinary necessities of image retouching Services. Be that as it may, you should be cautious while choosing the best one.Chat discussion end Type a message....

    ReplyDelete

  31. Photo Retouching is one of the most impressive services in photo editing. It helps to bring a positive vibe and look on the photos. Most of the end-level users are in great needs of Photo Retouching Services. But you need to be careful while selecting the best one.
    Chat conversation end
    Type a message...

    ReplyDelete

  32. Creative Banner is a focusing fact for any kinds of business institutions. Banner show your products identity which is provided by you. Manage your banner design service creatively by any professional designer to highlight your products. Cr eative banner grabs your customer’s attention.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Image Retouching is a standout amongst the most noteworthy administrations in Image altering. It expedites a positive vibe and look the Image. The majority of the end-level clients are in extraordinary necessities of image retouching Services. Be that as it may, you should be cautious while choosing the best one.Chat discussion end Type a message....

    ReplyDelete
  34. Photo Background Editor plays a key role in removing the background of the photo. The editor needs to remain highly careful while removing the background. The service is an essential one for the online business community.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Image Retouching is a standout amongst the most noteworthy administrations in Image altering. It expedites a positive vibe and look the Image. The majority of the end-level clients are in extraordinary necessities of image retouching Services. Be that as it may, you should be cautious while choosing the best one.Chat discussion end Type a message....

    ReplyDelete

  36. Photo Background Editor plays a key role in removing the background of the photo. The editor needs to remain highly careful while removing the background. The service is an essential one for the online business community.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Logo is the the symbol or representation of an Organization or company that identify that organization. Logo designing is to create that symbol..Logo Desging Adobe illustrator or photoshop is a powerful tool for logo designing. A suitable logo represents the activities, motive, aim of that organization in a visual way simply.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Image Retouching is a standout amongst the most noteworthy administrations in Image altering. It expedites a positive vibe and look the Image. The majority of the end-level clients are in extraordinary necessities of image retouching Services. Be that as it may, you should be cautious while choosing the best one.Chat discussion end Type a message....

    ReplyDelete
  39. Shadow Creation is the process to change the color of an image or video..Shadow Creation It means correcting the lighting, white color balance, red or blue color balance, so that the image looks more clear or natural

    ReplyDelete
  40. Image retouching service is on of the great services of Adobe Photoshop service. Removing spots or blemishes from images, as well as more advanced color correction work. We can remove unsightly marks, stain,Image retouching fold from any surface and ensure that your images are perfect in every way. We can eliminate the irregularities from the skin and also adjust the image color shades or erase it. We do this by creating an additional selection (path or a mask) of the model’s skin (face, hands, legs, etc.) Our designers can measure and correct the color values. Clone and Spot Healing tools remove irregularities. We can reduce and eliminate bags under the eyes, pimples, tattoos, birthmarks, etc

    ReplyDelete
  41. Image editing service Image Editing service. suppliers around the globe and modest rates, the work is submitted by the conveyance time. We offer our worldwide customers: Background Removal, Multiple Path, Clipping Path, Photo Restoration, Photo Neck Joint, Jewelry Photo Retouching, Product modifying, Color Correction, Image Mirror Effect, Deep Etching, Logo Design, flag configuration services.Zenith IT is one of the best image editing service provider company. We work all over the world. We mainly work in USA, UK, UAE, Australia, Denmark, Germany, France, Poland, Switzerland, Canada & Norway.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Image masking is a powerful background changer while clipping method does not work.Image Masking This process is used to change or remove the background of an image of a target object which has hairy, fuzzy or soft edge like a dog or curly hair of a girl or transparent background like glass.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Clipping path service is one kind of image editing Process where we select a important portion of an image and cut the unimportant part Clipping path We can delete the background or change background color to make it more attractive.

    ReplyDelete